Back to articles

Build an Addition or Buy a Larger Home? A Guide for Indiana Homeowners

October 8, 2025
8
 min read
Share:

As life changes, so do our requirements for a living space. And if you’re in a busier season of life, it’s common to feel a little cramped.

So whether you’re contending with the kids’ toys taking over the living room, a “home office” consisting of a laptop and kitchen counter, or are just tired of bumping into loved ones at the fridge (hey, it happens), this guide is for you.

By giving it a quick read, you’ll learn the pros and cons of your two main choices for getting more space at home: 

  • Moving into a larger house, or 
  • Exploring custom home additions in Indiana

By the end, the New Horizon crews feel confident you’ll know which suits you and your family best. Plus, you’ll learn a bonus option you may not have previously thought of, which is a great option for saving money when the budget is tight.

Let’s break it down.

The Case for Moving Into a Larger Home

Sometimes, the easiest solution is starting fresh. For homeowners, this can mean purchasing a larger, prebuilt home, or, what may be an even better solution, working with new home builders in Indiana to build from the ground up.

Here are a few advantages to moving into a larger home:

  • No Construction-Zone Stress: Anyone who’s gone through major home renovations knows it can be difficult to have crews, dust, and noise at your house during larger projects. 
  • Fresh Design: Starting out with the open layout, larger kitchen, or bathrooms you have in mind is always easier than renovating an existing space.
  • Neighborhood Choice: Choosing your neighborhood means the option to live closer to work, amenities you frequent, and even family and friends.

The Downside of Leaving Your Current Home

While moving into or building a new home is the right choice for many, there are a few potential drawbacks to be aware of. 

These include:

  • Higher Overall Costs: Selling fees, moving expenses, and higher home prices often cost more than homeowners expect. If budget is an issue, it may be better to stay put.
  • Market Uncertainty: The current housing market is competitive, and because of a lack of supply, finding the right home may be difficult without overpaying.
  • Leaving Memories Behind: If you’ve been in your home long—or during formative years for your family—it can be difficult to leave the neighborhood, memories, and the character of your home behind.

The Pros of a New Home Addition

Working with reputable home addition builders—especially here in our beloved state of Indiana—gives you the extra space you need without giving up the house you already know and love.

Here are a few advantages of a new home addition:

  • Keep Your Home: Home additions in Indiana allow you the gift of staying in the neighborhood and the home you love. Enough said. 
  • Increased Home Value: Additions often pay off when it’s time to sell—especially when thoughtfully designed for maximizing space and the flow of your home.
  • Cost Flexibility: With home additions, you can tackle projects as you’re financially able—rather than needing a large lump sum at the start of a project.

The Drawbacks of Home Additions

As with all major construction projects, home additions do have some drawbacks to be aware of.

These include:

  • At-Home Construction: This one is unavoidable. You’ll deal with dust, noise, and onsite workers for weeks, or potentially even months, while you go on living in your home.
  • Design Limitations: From zoning to having to tie into existing structural limitations, not every property can handle the addition you may be envisioning.
  • Budget Realities: While certainly less than building or purchasing a new home, additions can be quite costly, and truth be told, final expenses are often higher than homeowners anticipate.

Home Remodeling: A Middle Ground for Indiana Homeowners

If moving feels extreme, and a full addition out of reach, there is a middle ground: home remodeling in Indiana.

Upgrades like a finished basement, knocking out a wall, or modernizing a bathroom can make your home feel much larger—and more functional—without having to invest in a massive project.

In fact, for many homeowners, home remodeling services are all it takes to make a space feel brand new. The benefits of remodeling your home range from increased comfort to improved aesthetics and even more efficient at-home flows.

So What’s the Best Way to Expand Your Horizons?

The choice to move into a larger home, add an addition, or renovate your current space is a personal one. That being said, whichever route you choose, there’s still one more major consideration before going into the project: choosing the right contractor.

At New Horizon Builders, our crews are made up of experienced residential contractors who are committed to providing value. To us, that means quality workmanship, honesty, fairness, and trust—the reason we back all of our work with a full 10-year workmanship warranty.

So take the first step toward the addition, remodel, or new home build you’ve been dreaming of. Reach out today for a free quote and consultation—because your new horizons are just around the corner.

Related articles